Umpire Services
In an appraisal, an umpire is typically selected to resolve the items the two appraisers cannot agree on. RCM team members can be considered for umpire appointments; every appointment starts with an availability inquiry and a conflict and disclosure review.
- Which team members are available to serve as umpire, and in which states.
- Whether court-appointed umpire work should be described publicly.
Who it serves
- Appraisers on both sides of an appraisal who are jointly considering an umpire.
- Parties or courts seeking an umpire candidate, where the applicable process allows.
When it is relevant
- The appraisers have exchanged positions and differences remain.
- The appraisers need to agree on an umpire, or an umpire must be selected under the process the policy or jurisdiction provides.
What we will ask for
- Names of the insured, the carrier, both appraisers, and any counsel or representatives — for conflict review.
- The property state and approximate location.
- The selection method (agreement of appraisers, court appointment, or other) and any deadline.
- After acceptance: each appraiser’s position and supporting documentation, through an agreed secure channel.
Do not send documents or sensitive details through the website. After an assignment is reviewed we agree on a secure way to exchange files.
What you receive
- A written disclosure of relevant relationships before appointment, so both sides can evaluate it.
- Agreed procedures for submissions, inspection (if any), and communication with both appraisers.
- A written decision on the items submitted, in the form the applicable process requires.
Limitations
- An umpire must be acceptable under the applicable policy and law. Disclosure does not by itself guarantee acceptance by either side.
- Availability is never assumed. A response to an inquiry is not an appointment.
- Qualification and appointment requirements vary by state and policy, and are reviewed for each matter.
- This page is general information, not legal advice.
How it works
Availability inquiry
Tell us the parties, location, and timing. We confirm whether a team member may be available.
Conflict and disclosure review
We check for relationships with the parties, appraisers, and representatives and disclose anything relevant.
Appointment and procedures
Once both sides agree (or the appointment is made), we confirm terms and how submissions will be handled.
Review of submissions
We review both appraisers’ positions and documentation, and inspect when the procedure calls for it.
Written decision
We document our decision on the items in dispute.
This shows how an assignment generally moves forward. It is an illustration, not a live status tracker for any file.
Ask about umpire services
Send a short inquiry. We review every request for conflicts, availability, and fit before confirming anything.